| Platinum | Hive and Honey |
| Gold | Hive and Honey Smoothie Bar |
| Silver | The Sweet Praxis |
| Bronze | Hope Cafe Coffeehouse |
| Top Pick | 210 Teas |
| Top Pick | Brewer Union Cafe |
| Top Pick | Cafe Kubal |
| Top Pick | Crazy Daisies |
| Top Pick | Finger Lakes Coffee |
| Top Pick | Pawsitivitea Cny Cafe and Cat Lounge |
| Top Pick | Recess Coffee House & Roastery |