| Platinum | Speras Meat & Grocery |
| Gold | Mazzye's Meats |
| Silver | Liehs & Steigerwald |
| Bronze | Cummo's Meat Market |
| Top Pick | Best Market |
| Top Pick | M.Ascioti Meatballs & More |
| Top Pick | Nojaim Bros Super Mkt |
| Top Pick | Side Hill Farmers Meats & Market |
| Top Pick | Syracuse Casing |