| Platinum | Angry Garlic |
| Gold | Big Awesome BBQ |
| Silver | Mamacitas |
| Bronze | King David's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | A Mano Kitchen & Bar |
| Top Pick | Brewer Union Cafe |
| Top Pick | Mi Pueblo Cafe |
| Top Pick | North Star Nutrition |
| Top Pick | Rise N Shine Diner |
| Top Pick | The Preserve at 405 |
| Tully's Good Times Erie Blvd | |
| Twin Trees Restaurant |