| Platinum | Lit Actually Romance Bookshop |
| Gold | Love & Libros Bookshop |
| Silver | Books & Melodies |
| Silver | Books End |
| Bronze | That's What She Read |
| Top Pick | Barnes & Noble |
| Top Pick | Golden Bee Bookshop |
| Top Pick | Parthenon Books |
| Top Pick | Syracuse Cultural Workers |
| Top Pick | The Book Cellar |