| Platinum | Brooklyn Pickle |
| Gold | Vince's Gourmet Imports |
| Silver | Fair Deli Mart |
| Silver | Speras Meat & Grocery |
| Silver | Wegmans Sub Shop |
| Bronze | Darwin |
| Bronze | The Preserve at 405 |
| Top Pick | Byrne Dairy |
| Top Pick | Liehs and Steigerwald |
| Top Pick | Panera Bread |
| Top Pick | The Curd Nerd |