| Platinum | King David's Restaurant |
| Gold | Syracuse Halal Gyro |
| Silver | Baghdad Restaurant |
| Bronze | Pita Dream |
| Top Pick | Goodies Mediterranean Grill & Cuisine |
| Top Pick | Kalamata Pita |
| Top Pick | Kiki's Authentic Greek Food |
| Top Pick | Munjed's Middle Eastern Cafe |
| Top Pick | Nestico's |