| Platinum | CNY Auto Spa |
| Gold | Rotella's Body Shop |
| Silver | Sauve Brothers |
| Bronze | Northside Collision Center |
| Top Pick | Canetta's Collision |
| Top Pick | Carubba Collision |
| Top Pick | Jeffrey's Auto Body |
| Top Pick | John's Auto Care |
| Top Pick | K & C Auto Body & Service |
| Top Pick | West Herr East Syracuse Chevy |