| Platinum | Hive and Honey |
| Gold | Fingerlakes Coffee Roasters |
| Silver | Cafe Kubal |
| Bronze | Salt City Coffee |
| Top Pick | Aurora's Cafe and Gifts |
| Top Pick | FreedomOfEspresso |
| Top Pick | H. Grey Supply Co. |
| Top Pick | Hope Cafe Coffeehouse |
| Top Pick | Recess Coffee House & Roastery |
| Top Pick | White Rabbit Roasting Co |