| Platinum | Daniella's Fresh Seafood and Pasta House |
| Gold | Fish Cove |
| Silver | The York |
| Bronze | The Clam Bar |
| Top Pick | Barado's On The Water |
| Top Pick | Brewer Union Cafe |
| Top Pick | My Crab Spot |
| Top Pick | The Fish Friar |
| Top Pick | The Spinning Wheel Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Westvale Fish Cove |