| Platinum | Tangy Tomato |
| Gold | Robbie T's |
| Silver | Paladino's Pizza |
| Bronze | Apizza Regionale |
| Bronze | Mario & Salvo's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Paladino's Cicero Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pavone's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pies Guys Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | The Preserve at 405 |
| Top Pick | Toss 'n' Fire Wood Fired Pizza |
| Top Pick | Twin Trees Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Varsity Pizza |