| Platinum | Francesca's Cucina |
| Gold | Pastabilities |
| Silver | Santangelo's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Apizza Regionale |
| Top Pick | Angotti's Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Avicolli's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Basil Leaf Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Francescas Pizza Liverpool |
| Top Pick | Il Limone |
| Top Pick | Joey's Italian Restaurant & Pronto Joeys |
| Top Pick | The Preserve at 405 |
| Top Pick | Vicinos Brick and Brew |
| Sbarro |