| Platinum | Atlantic Seafood |
| Platinum | Fish Cove |
| Gold | Doug's Fish Fry |
| Silver | Bayberry Fish Cove |
| Bronze | The Fish Friar |
| Top Pick | Faegan's Cafe & Pub |
| Top Pick | Fish Cove Shop City Plaza |
| Top Pick | Kitty Hoynes Irish Pub & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Clam Bar |
| Top Pick | The Retreat |