| Platinum | The Curd Nerd |
| Gold | Vince's Gourmet Imports |
| Silver | PMA Foods |
| Bronze | Buttercup Cheese |
| Top Pick | Best Market |
| Top Pick | Callee1945 |
| Top Pick | Cheese Filled Company |
| Top Pick | Lombardi's Import Market |
| Top Pick | Thanos Import Market |
| Top Pick | Wegmans Old World Cheese |