| Platinum | Water Street Bagel Co. |
| Gold | Bagelicious of Bayberry |
| Silver | Bruegger's Bagels |
| Bronze | Cazenovia and Dewitt Bagel |
| Top Pick | Dewitt Bagelry |
| Top Pick | Dogs On Wheels |
| Top Pick | Dunkin' |
| Top Pick | NY Bagel, Cortland NY |
| Top Pick | Price Chopper Bakery |
| Top Pick | Sugar Top Bake Shoppe |