| Platinum | Big Four Tire Warehouse |
| Gold | Masello's Auto Service |
| Silver | John's Auto Care |
| Bronze | Valvoline Instant Oil Change |
| Top Pick | Auburn Auto Group |
| Top Pick | Burkhart Auto |
| Top Pick | Davco Performance Automotive |
| Top Pick | Hanks Auto Service |
| Top Pick | Mike's Auto Service Center |
| Top Pick | Mike's Midas North Syracuse |