| Platinum | Brooklyn Pickle |
| Gold | Gino and Joes Cheesesteak |
| Gold | Gino's Cheesesteak & Onion |
| Silver | Wegmans Sub Shop |
| Bronze | Vince's Gourmet Imports |
| Top Pick | Darwin on Clinton |
| Top Pick | Dibella's Subs |
| Top Pick | Paladino's The Deli |
| Top Pick | PB & J's Lunch Box |
| Top Pick | The Preserve at 405 |