| Platinum | Alto Cinco |
| Gold | Ponchito's Taqueria |
| Silver | Boom Boom Mex Mex Taqueria |
| Bronze | Margaritas Mexican Cantina |
| Top Pick | Azteca Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Carmelita's Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Rio Grande Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | San Miguel Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Tres Primos |
| Top Pick | XO Taco |