| Platinum | Peace, Love, and Cupcakes |
| Platinum | The Sweet Praxis |
| Gold | Biscotti Cafe & Pastry Shop |
| Gold | Heid's of Liverpool |
| Silver | Sno Top |
| Bronze | Gannon's Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Carvel Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Carvel North Syracuse |
| Top Pick | Peter's Polar Parlor |
| Top Pick | Sugar Top Bake Shoppe |