| Platinum | Gannon's Ice Cream |
| Gold | Carvel Ice Cream |
| Silver | Stewart's Shops |
| Bronze | Big Dipper |
| Bronze | Vicky Tasty Treats |
| Top Pick | Arctic Island Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Bailiwick Market and Cafe |
| Top Pick | Byrne Dairy |
| Top Pick | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Top Pick | Delicioso Coco Helado Syracuse |
